Marketing students go head-to-head with USA TODAY Ad Meter

Classroom learnings come to life with real-world application of advertising concepts, consumer insights 

By Haley Fite

In a unique intersection of classroom learning and the biggest night in advertising, Lindner Introduction to Marketing students took center stage in USA TODAY’s 2026 Ad Meter School Spotlight program, offering their own rankings of Super Bowl commercials — and gaining real-world experience in the process.

More than 300 UC students participated, evaluating ads alongside industry professionals and contributing their scores to the renowned Ad Meter platform.

“Marketing (and especially advertising) are such applied fields, so one of the best ways students can learn about them is by experiencing them in action rather than just reading about them,” said Summer Shelton, PhD, assistant professor-educator of marketing. “Participating in USA TODAY’s Ad Meter rankings gave our students the opportunity to evaluate real campaigns, apply concepts from class, and think critically about what makes these $8 million Super Bowl ads effective or worth it for a brand (or not).”

Marketing (and especially advertising) are such applied fields, so one of the best ways students can learn about them is by experiencing them in action rather than just reading about them.

Summer Shelton, PhD, assistant professor-educator of marketing

Budweiser’s “American Icons” emerged as a standout favorite, capturing the top spot among both students and professional audiences.

“This ad is perfect,” Emmit Orlowski, BBA ’29, told USA TODAY. “It encapsulates the true American spirit, from the famous Budweiser Clydesdale to the American icon, the bald eagle.”

For students like Orlowski, the experience was more than an assignment — it was a chance to think like marketers in real time. His comment reflects the depth of analysis students applied, considering not just entertainment value, but branding, emotional storytelling and cultural resonance.

The project exemplifies experiential learning at its finest. Rather than simply studying advertising theory, students actively applied frameworks used by professionals, critiquing campaigns in a live, high-stakes environment. Guided by faculty with industry experience, they engaged in hands-on evaluation, data analysis and critical discussion — skills essential to modern marketing careers.